CAST's 'Tenor' in tune for a first-rate farce

By Ruby Nancy

Ken Ludwig’s “Lend Me A Tenor” is a farce that earns its many big laughs. The popular playwright has set this show at a fancy hotel in Cleveland, circa 1938, and it has a cute period feel that just adds to the jokes.

The setting and the show’s focus on an opera company and its guest tenor also call for a glam look, which means many of the performers get to rush around doing ridiculous things while wearing fabulous clothes. A pretty sweet gig for the actors, for sure, but when the show is done well, it is also a lot of fun for the rest of us.

In the current Clinton Area Showboat Theatre production, directed by Craig A. Miller (CAST’s producing artistic director), fun is definitely not in short supply.

Joshua Estrada stars as Max, the put-upon opera company staffer charged with keeping an eye on the out-of-town talent, and the nervous intensity he lends the character is perfectly done. All a-dither about the responsibility associated with baby-sitting a temperamental star — and anxious about the proposal he tendered to his boss’ daughter, who is ambivalent about their possibilities — Estrada’s Max is a spring wound so tight it probably hurts.

This performer is wildly engrossed in the role, and you can practically hear a “sproing” when his eyes bug out at each of a series of hilarious misfortunes. He is slightly spastic without being twitchy, and his fantastic line readings draw huge laughs every single time.

Kay Ann Allmand is also hilarious as Maggie, Max’s erstwhile (and equally uptight) girlfriend. Her facial expressions change quickly, revealing thoughts as swiftly as they cross her character’s mind. Large, expressive eyes and a gift for compact physical shtick round out her superb performance.

Will Morgan is funny and slightly larger-than-life as Tito Merelli, the star tenor, and his belligerent paroxysms are quite entertaining (though he did slip in and out of the cheesy accent Merelli is supposed to have). Alison Nicole Luff, who plays the operatic Mrs. Merelli, is perfectly fiery, playing well off of Morgan’s bluster (though I wished the tailoring and fabric of her costume had been from the period).

As the fawning, sarcastic hotel bellhop, Steven Piechocki almost walks away with the scenes he’s in, and Mark X. Laskowski is very good as Saunders, the opera company director who loves to pontificate. Playing the fussy Julia, from the opera company’s board of directors, the ever-effervescent Nicole Horton is as excellent as usual. As Diana, a local opera singer who hopes to make it big — one way or another — Jennifer Gilbert turns in excellent work. (Her big scene with Morgan, when Merelli totally misunderstands her meaning of the word “professional,” is absolutely hilarious.)

An all-together excellent production, this “Lend Me A Tenor” is a first-class farce. Don’t you dare miss it.